Thu 30 Jul 2009
The Fault Lies with Me
Posted by kevo' under Blast from the Past, Reviews
[2] Comments

(out of 4)
Review: Uta Kata
My ex-roommate, along with many others whom I know, never understood why I force myself to finish anime I do not find enjoyable. I really don’t like to drop shows, so if I’m a few episodes in, I am probably going to go to the bitter end. It’s not really that Uta Kata is bad, it’s that I’m not a member of its target audience. As much as I will try to be objective in this review, keep in mind that I didn’t enjoy the show because its concepts, themes, and lessons simply did not appeal to me.

The two main characters
14-year-old Tachibana Ichika (cv. Honda Youko), meets magical girl Hatune Miku, err I mean Kuroki Manatsu (cv. Asamo Masumi) at the beginning of summer (that’s the only jab at the character design I promise). The two then spend the summer in various escapades, but each episode Ichika turns into a different flavor of magical girl and this solves all the episode’s problems. Ok, it’s not that simple and the plot and premise is actually a lot more professionally written than I give it credit for. Uta Kata is labeled a “magical girl” anime because it contains magical girls and there are cool costumes, but it is quite a different breed than its contemporary anime. Unlike other magical girl anime that come to mind, such as Sailor Moon and Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha, Uta Kata has a slightly more mature and edgy shadow to it. Uta Kata contains references to things such as depression and child abuse, and serious scenes and situations appear more frequently as the series progress.
The writing is competent and the pacing is alright. In 12 episodes it did feel like Uta Kata did everything it wanted to. The structure of episodes early on seemed repetitively similar – Ichika and friends go somewhere, dramatic thing happens, magical girl transformation,
everything is ok now – but the overarching plot does kick in eventaully. Friendship is a cool motif that is explored in the series, mainly in the form of Ichika and Manatsu’s relationship. Ichika’s friends are explored to an extent, most of the “mature” topics in the show are relating to them, but it really felt that they were almost background characters sometimes.
The art is circa 2004, but has a nice clean look with crisp lines and a soft finish. The art style is very much forgettable, and characters outside of Manatsu and Ichika are pretty forgettable visually. One unique and cool thing about Uta Kata is the costume design for magical girl Ichika. In each episode, a different famous mangaka designs the costume, and its cool to see the interesting ways different people interpret the different elements that each iteration of magical girl Ichika is supposed to represent. The guest costume designers include the likes of Kobayashi Jin (School Rumble), Rikudo Koshi (Excel Saga), and Ken Akamatsu (Love Hina). The overall costume design in the series is very good, though Manatsu kinda looks plain in her generic magical dress.
Uta Kata is the last time I watch an anime just for its music. Uta Kata’s music was so good that I jumped right in and started to watch this anime without so much as looking up what its about. When the anime didn’t really appeal to me the music was still good, so that kinda pulled me through. savage Genius absolutely hit it out of the ballpark with the OP and ED, but what is often overlooked is the amazing score for the series. The instrumental theme and melodic background music is beautiful and works well with the show. Besides that, the voice acting in Uta Kata is nothing special. Michiru is a forgettable role for Yukari Tamura that is great for obscure fanboy trivia.
The ED is quite famous, though I like the OP a little better
Uta Kata is not bad, far from it. It’s mainly my fault for starting a show that I have no interest in that I otherwise would not have watched. Uta Kata’s storytelling was passable, but it told a story I didn’t want to here. The themes and deeper meanings in the show were well done, but they didn’t appeal to me. And the climax of the show was really, really cheesy. The lesson here, kids, is to research your anime just a tiny bit before diving in. At least read the blurb that tells you what the anime is generally about.
Subscribe


she stops being a cold hearted bitch spewing awesome one-liners and dissing Araragi, she becomes a strangely mellow bitch spewing awesome one-liners and dissing Araragi. Hitagi is the only reason I would consider fixating the “comedy” genre onto this show. Hitagi feels that she owes Araragi something for introducing her to Oshino and solving her problem. In this episode, character development reveals that Araragi is a bit of a pussy when it comes to women, basically being too scared to take up any of Hitagi’s offerings, despite undoubtedly being attracted to her. Hitagi is a very interesting character herself, and the relationship between our two protagonists will be fruitful. This show also introduces a loli (see left), who has twintails AND fangs. Formulaically, I assume (which is probably a nono with a Shinbo anime) she also has a mysterious problem/power to be fixed. In conclusion, show rules bye.





